Filed Under: Appellate Law Municipal Law
Wisconsin Court of Appeals Allows Inclusion of Parking Lot Income in Milwaukee Property Tax Assessment
In Milwaukee Block 10 Properties v. City of Milwaukee, the Wisconsin Court of Appeals reaffirmed two key principles in its reversal of a circuit court decision which ordered the City of Milwaukee to revise its property tax assessment for the Aloft Hotel. First, Wisconsin affords substantial deference to property tax assessments prepared by municipalities. Property […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law Litigation
Wisconsin Court of Appeals Strikes Down Insurer’s Limitation on Underinsured Motorist Coverage
The Wisconsin Court of Appeals recently held that Wisconsin law precludes enforcement of a provision in an insurance policy that purported to limit underinsured motorist (“UIM”) coverage to only those insureds who sustain bodily injury or death. Ryan Johnson died from injuries sustained in a collision involving an underinsured vehicle. Johnson’s minor son, Elliot Brey, […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law Employment & Labor Law Litigation
U.S. Supreme Court Holds Employment Protection Reaches Sexual Orientation and Transgender Status
Title VII is the portion of the federal Civil Rights Act that prohibits employers from discriminating on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, and national origin. It was first adopted by Congress in 1964. Last week, in a 6-3 ruling, the U.S. Supreme Court interpreted Title VII to prohibit discrimination on the basis of […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law Government Law Municipal Law
Court Reiterates that Not All Government Actions that Diminish Property Value Are Compensable
State and local governments have a variety of powers. They can take private property for public use, but they have to fairly compensate the property owner. They can also use their police power—a broad array of authority to protect public health and safety—to regulate the use of property. The Wisconsin Court of Appeals’ recent decision […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law Business Law
Court of Appeals Applies Economic Loss Doctrine to Subcontractor Dispute under Interrelated Contracts Theory
The Wisconsin Court of Appeals recently issued a decision expanding the economic loss doctrine to horizontal claims by subcontractors who lack contractual privity. See Mechanical, Inc. v. Venture Electrical Contractors, Inc., No. 2018AP2380 (Apr. 22, 2020). The issue was whether one subcontractor could assert a negligence claim seeking purely economic losses (in this case delay […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law Business Law
Seventh Circuit Upholds Dismissal of Subcontractor’s Meritless Claims for Damages Based on Customary Bid Negotiations with General Contractor
Earlier this week, the Seventh Circuit affirmed the district court’s order granting our client’s, Annex Construction, LLC, motion for summary judgment dismissing all claims brought against it by a framing subcontractor, Skyrise Construction Group, LLC. See Skyrise Construction Group, LLC v. Annex Construction, LLC, Case No. 19-1461 (7th Cir. April 21, 2020). In a unanimous […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law Litigation
Stafford Rosenbaum Team Wins Unanimous Ruling from Wisconsin Supreme Court
Today, six months after oral argument, the Wisconsin Supreme Court unanimously ruled in favor of our client, Lynnea Landsee-Pulikkila, and reversed a 2019 decision of the Wisconsin Court of Appeals. The majority opinion, authored by Justice Ann Walsh Bradley, recognized that the court of appeals “jumped the gun” by imposing a constructive trust in this […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law
Court of Appeals Declines Request to Further Complicate Administrative Rule-Making Process
The Court of Appeals recently rejected an attempt to further complicate Wisconsin’s administrative rule-making process, and solidified the ability of agencies to respond to public comments during rulemaking. Applegate-Bader Farm, LLC v. Wisconsin Department of Revenue, 2020 WI App 7, stemmed from an administrative rule proposed by Wisconsin Department of Revenue (DOR) relating to the […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law
Court of Appeals Decision Complicates Insureds’ Ability to Obtain Coverage From Claims-Made Insurers
The Wisconsin Court of Appeals recently issued an insurance coverage decision likely to induce heartburn for risk management personnel responsible for deciding whether and when to notify their liability insurers regarding speculative future claims that may arise. See Vistelar, LLC v. Cincinnati Spec. Ins. Co., No. 2019AP633 (Feb. 25, 2020). At issue in this case […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law Business Law
Wisconsin Supreme Court Declines To Change Successor Liability Law
In 2018, we flagged an unpublished, per curiam decision by the Wisconsin Court of Appeals as unusual. It seemed that the court of appeals, while adhering to the most recent precedent, was strongly signaling that it thought that precedent was wrongly decided and that the Wisconsin Supreme Court should revisit the scope of exceptions to […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law
Wisconsin Supreme Court Procedural Orders Limit Circuit Court Authority To Issue Injunctions
The Wisconsin Constitution grants circuit courts the power to “issue all writs necessary in aid of [their] jurisdiction.” Wis. Const. art. VII, § 8. And the Legislature has expressly authorized circuit courts to issue injunctions. Wis. Stat. §§ 813.01, 813.02. Yet, in two unsigned and unpublished procedural orders issued this past spring, the Supreme Court […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law
7th Circuit Finds Broad Breach of Contract Exclusion in Prof Services Liability Policy Unenforceable
Recently, in Crum & Forster Specialty Insurance Co. v. DVO, Inc., Slip Op., Case No. 18-2571 (7th Cir. Sept. 23, 2019) (“Slip Op.”), the Seventh Circuit held that, under Wisconsin insurance policy interpretation principles, an insurer may not avoid its coverage responsibilities by invoking an exclusion that is broad enough to fully encompass the scope […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law
Court of Appeals Weighs in on Class Action Cert Issues Under Federal Standard Recently Adopted in WI
Last month, District I of the Wisconsin Court of Appeals was provided an opportunity to review a circuit court’s grant of a motion for class certification under the newly-revised version of Wis. Stat. § 803.08, which adopted the language and scope of FRCP 23, the federal class certification analogue. See Harwood v. Wheaton Franciscan Services, Inc., et […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law Government Relations Municipal Law
Seventh Circuit Reaffirms Stringent Standards for Municipal Liability in Civil Rights Actions
Since the United States Supreme Court’s seminal decision in Monell v. New York Department of Social Services, a municipality can be only found liable for civil rights claims brought under 42 U.S.C § 1983 if a plaintiff can show that a policy or custom of the municipality caused the violation of his or her constitutional […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law
Right to Appeal an Order on a Motion to Compel Arbitration: Wisconsin Supreme Court Makes It Final
Buried in many modern contracts (from standard construction industry contracts to employment agreements, and from consumer contracts to mortgages and leases) are agreements to arbitrate any existing or future disputes. These arbitration provisions may appear innocuous, but, when a subsequent dispute develops between the contracting parties and one party prefers to be in court, a […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law
What the U.S. Supreme Court’s Bethune-Hill Decision Means for Legislative Intervenors in Wisconsin
Earlier this week, the U.S. Supreme Court decided in Virginia House of Delegates v. Bethune-Hill, No. 18-281 (U.S. June 17, 2019), that one chamber of the Virginia legislature lacked legal standing to appeal a federal court order requiring that some legislative districts be withdrawn. Virginia’s Attorney General had defended the districts in the trial court, but […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law Employment & Labor Law
Use It Or Lose It: SCOTUS Ruling Means Employer Defense To Discrimination Claims Can Be Waived
On June 3, 2019, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously held that failure of an employee to file a discrimination claim with the EEOC prior to bringing a discrimination lawsuit does not deprive a court of jurisdiction over the suit. That means that an employer can waive the defense to a discrimination claim based on failure […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law
Supreme Court Finds Unexpected Difference between Corporations and Limited Liability Companies
In Marx v. Morris, 2019 WI 34, the Wisconsin Supreme Court interpreted the Wisconsin LLC Act in an unexpected way. Specifically, Marx held that LLC members may bring suit in their capacity as members, instead of on behalf of the LLC, against other members, even when the harm alleged is primarily to the LLC. This deviates from corporate […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law Government Relations
Noncompliance with Notice-of-Claim Statute Is Affirmative Defense, Must Be Pleaded
Wis. Stat. § 893.80(1d) requires a potential claimant to provide notice, including “an itemized statement of the relief sought,” to a government entity within 120 days of the event giving rise to a potential suit. In Maple Grove Country Club Inc. v. Maple Grove Estates Sanitary District, 2019 WI 43, the Wisconsin Supreme Court recently held […]
Filed Under: Appellate Law Government Relations
State Can Raise New Argument in Civil Forfeiture Action, Even After Dismissing Criminal Charges
Some civil and criminal cases rely on indistinguishable facts. However, a recent Wisconsin Court of Appeals decision – Wisconsin v. Scott, et. al., 2017AP1345 – demonstrated that the parties need not make indistinguishable arguments in each case. In 2016, police seized drugs, money and vehicles pursuant to a search warrant for the Scotts’ property. However, it […]
